That was the opening music to Star Wars, in case you didn’t know…
I love Star Wars. I love everything about Star Wars. I spend countless hours at work reading about Star Wars things that weren’t even in the movie. I’m sorry, that’s just who I am. I could talk about Star Wars all day. From the evils of the Empire, to justifying the deaths of independent private contractors who were still working on the second Death Star. I realize that it is probably a little sad, but at least I’m not at the conventions, wearing a costume, proposing some sort of Mos Eisley Cantina type wedding. Not yet, anyways…
But I digress. If you know me, or even if you don’t know me, it is important to know that I believe my opinion to be fact. I know, it’s a terrible way to be but that’s just how I am. I blame my English teacher, who once asked my opinion, and then told me all the ways I was wrong. From that day forth, I was never wrong. I tell you that to tell you this: This blog is about the facts that I have determined are facts. I believe there is a best Star Wars movie. I believe there is a worst Star Wars movie. And right now, I plan to tell you which is which, in what I like to call a “ranking system.” I invented it.
For this article, I’m basing my ranks on characters, story, fight scene (there is one in every movie), and my own feelings. And my feelings outweigh everything else. Just simple facts. Now ranking from The Phantom Menace to Return of the Jedi, from worst to best.
6. The Phantom MenaceThere are so many things wrong with this movie, it seems impossible to start saying anything good about it. It pains me to watch it. I feel like Lucas personally slapped me in the face when he walked out with this move on film and declared “Well, this will do…” No George. It won’t do. But, while I sit in contempt over this pile of wretch that is in fact the numerically first Star Wars movie, I must look at it from the good as well as the bad.
The Good: While I say there are so many things wrong with the movie, there are some hot points. Qui-Gon Jinn is a hot point. Liam Neeson seemingly reached down into the doo doo mountain that was this movie, and almost single handedly made it worth watching. His attitude alone made me glad he was in the movie. From his training, we see why Obi Wan was the way he was. And, if it weren’t for Qui-Gon, there would be no reason for a series, as he discovered Anakin and demanded he be allowed to train as a Jedi. If it weren’t for him, Hayden Christianson would still be on Tatooine, riding speeders with Uncle Owen.
The next touch of good will be a combined effort. Ray Parks as Darth Maul, and of course the unbelievable fight scene. Ray Parks is an outstanding actor. (Forget for a moment that he was punished with playing Toad in the original X-Men movie…) Darth Maul is the quintessential bad guy. Vader is angry for a reason. He hates because he has to. Maul on the other hand, just hates to hate. No back story, no home world, nothing. All we know is that he looks like the devil, and fights like a mad man. Plus, he’s got that sweet double lightsaber and motorcycle thing. And that fight scene. I could write an entire entry on just the fight scene. The first real lightsaber duel in 16 years, and it left everything else in the dust. With the power of CGI, we didn’t have to worry about stop motion, untrained actors, or the awkwardly huge suit Vader had to wear the whole time. We got man vs man-thing vs another man, and it was awesome. Qui-Gon was the star of the beginning, but Obi Wan won our hearts in the end.
The Bad: Now that I have said something good, I must admit that the movie over-all is crap. I hate it. If it comes on tv, I contemplate setting my hair on fire. It’s just that bad. Jar Jar and the stupid Gungans. Pod racing. That little kid actor. It was all too much for the good up there to overcome. Jar Jar, whether or not he is racist, is in fact stupid. The way he talks makes me want to mute the television. Sure, maybe he was a good way to keep little children interested in the movie. But the fact remains that this is a series of movies that has had the same loyal fan base for 22 years. And yes, there are new fans popping up every day, but that doesn’t mean you should insult your loyals, and give them some crappy “comic relief” character. That’s what C-3PO and R2D2 are for. That’s legit Star Wars humor. Nothing flashy, or stupid. The Gungans themselves are lame. They fight with blue balls. Really? Do I need to go there? And if their racist undertones don’t upset you enough, according to wookieepedia, an individual Gungan is called “a gung.” Stupid.
I hated the actor playing young Anakin. He sucked. Nothing about him said “Supreme Dark Lord of the Sith” to me. Maybe that was the point. I don’t know.
Pod racing is a waste of film. When I see this movie, because of the amount of time devoted to Pod Racing, it is as though the story was so empty, they needed something to devote a solid hour to. Pod racing was born. I don’t have a problem with a brief mention of it, or maybe a little screen time devoted to it. But there was no reason for the entire movie to be all Dukes of Hazzard-y with the racing. Like I said earlier, its true that Lucas wanted to attract and keep a new generation of fans. But this was not the way. Not the way at all. I did enjoy the part in the Pod race where Anakin’s racer blows up, and he gets all angry and says that he’s going to become evil after that. Oh wait, that didn’t happen.
Speaking of Pod racing, I can really only see one reason it was in there. It was there to justify how Anakin was just a good pilot. Great, because later in the movie Anakin has to save the day by flying a ship he’s never heard of into space and blow up an attacking Trade Federation ship. So, Anakin is a great pilot. I’m glad we know this now BECAUSE IT HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE ORIGINAL TRILOGY!!! Obi Wan mentions it one time to Luke, and all of a sudden Anakin is some prodigy child that can fly a ship from Naboo that he has never even laid eyes on?? If you wanted to show Anakin as a skilled pilot, why not wait until Episodes II and III. Oh, you did that? Then what was the point of the ridiculous flying baby Anakin did?
5. Return of the Jedi
I may get a lot of flak for this one, but I just don’t care. It’s how I feel. It is by far the weakest of the original trilogy, and tomorrow I may feel differently and place this one at number 4. But for now, this is where it goes.
The Good: This movie is good, for the most part. There isn’t much I can complain about, but what I don’t like drops it very far down the list. This movie is nowhere near as bad as Phantom Menace, but it just isn’t as good as the others. There is good in this movie, there is. Vader redeeming himself is the game winner for me. We all knew he was good, or at least wanted to believe it was true. Luke said it himself. And he does in fact fulfill the prophecy; he was the chosen one. Suck it Mace!! Even though you can’t see his eyes through the mask, you just know he had a pissed off look on his face when the Emperor was laying it to Luke with that Force lightening. Nothing like a little abuse to make daddy throw you down the ventilator shaft. Good thing 2, Jabba the Hutt. I love Jabba. I loved Jabba as a kid. Jabba was the character I remembered most from my childhood. He was huge, commanded respect, and somehow got the Princess into that gold bikini. Straight pimpin. Luke was a lot darker in this movie, which I loved. You see that he’s right on the edge of not only the Light Side, but also his sanity. It just seems like he could lose it at any second, but still seems to hold on, even when facing dear old dad. I loved the Sarlacc pit, until they ruined it with the re-release. There was something so ominous about it originally… And, as mentioned above you can not! beat Leia in that gold bikini. Fact!
The Bad:Like I said, I don’t think this is a bad movie, but it’s just not as good as the others. However, there is some wrong with this movie. When Luke takes Darth Vader’s/Anakin’s helmet off, there is no telling what is under there. I was so ready to see some horrid, beastly, disfigured man underneath. However, we were stuck with a pale, wrinkly, scarred fat man. With an egg shaped head. Not intimidating at all. Underneath that suit, Vader was like every bully we had in middle school, just a very white guy who probably still pees the bed. The best thing to come out of the way Anakin looks with his helmet off is this:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3eZBevXohCI
Ewoks. I hate Ewoks. I don’t care that Willow played one. Nothing but teddy bears, in my opinion. And there is no way, NO WAY teddy bears could have destroyed all the stuff that was sent to their planet. Primative weaponry will not beat an AT-AT. It just can’t be done.
Han Solo is a wuss. When we first meet Han Solo, he is the lovable space pirate with a heart of gold. Like Jack Sparrow, only less gay. Han always came through in a pinch, but was always looking out for himself. Reward was all he could think about, when he wasn’t thinking about hookin up with Leia. In The Empire Strikes Back, Han is desperate to get away from Hoth so he can do what? Cover his tail by paying off Jabba. Sure, he cares about the rebellion, but not as much as he cares about not dying at the hands of a morbidly obese Hutt. But by this film, he’s a general? Did the time he spent in carbonite take away some of his back bone? Sure, fight for the cause you believe in, but do it your way. Poser.
Oh, and what was up with the way Luke killed that Rancor monster?? He’s claiming to be a Jedi Knight, and he has to use a skull to hit the button on the other side of the room to slam the door? Come on Luke, give me some Jedi powers. That fight scene was a waste.
4. Attack of the Clones
Yeah, I think this is better than Jedi, get over it.
The Good: I didn’t think this was very good for a long time. I placed it right around Phantom as far as quality for a long time. It took a rewatch several years later to change my mind. I often find myself changing its number with Jedi up there. What was good about this movie, is the lack of awkward tension between Anakin and Padme. She was way too old for him in the first movie, and this changed it up a bit. Obi Wan has come into his own by this movie, and his prominence as a Jedi Master shows. Plus, he got that beard. Jar Jar is gone for the most part. We get to see just how manipulative Palpatine really is, and how he tricks his way into power. Plus, one of the coolest bad guys in all the Star Wars galaxy is here, Mr. Boba Fett. Why is he so angry? You’d be pissed too if you watched your father(?) get demolished by that Jedi scum Mace Windu. Let us not forget the epic battle between the Jedi and Dooku’s droids on Geonosis. That was cool. Plus, Yoda comes sweeping in with that clone army, leading the troops. Yoda is ballin, no matter how you look at it. Never once have I felt like Yoda didn’t give enough to the franchise. He’s like Brett Favre. Even when things were down, Yoda brings it.
And of course, Anakin gets his hand cut off. The beginning of his transformation to machine is right here in Episode II. Every time I see that robot hand at the end of the flick, I get a little goosebumpy. You just know what it leads to.
Oh, and it’s the first time you hear a little inkling of the Imperial March. The clone troops marching, and all of a sudden THAT’S the music you hear? So foreshadowing!
The Bad: Anakin is such a whinny baby in this movie. After seeing this one, I felt like Ol’ Hayden couldn’t handle the role. Then I realized he was probably written that way. I just don’t like the most evil villain of all time complaining about everything all the time. R2D2 had way too many abilities in this one. His little jet boosters, just didn’t do it for me. I mean, why didn’t he just use those on Dagobah when he was stuck under water in that swamp? The fight scene here was pretty good, despite Anakin’s inability to actually act like a Jedi and use some restraint. Geeze, you’re 18 years old, listen to your bearded master. You deserved to get your arm cut off.
Speaking of Anakin, let’s reflect briefly on the slaughter of the Sand People. That was very Darth Vader. Anakin was angry, so he lashed out. That is what makes Vader Vader. He can’t control his rage like he should. I don’t have a problem with that. I do have a problem with the sadness that followed. It’s as though he couldn’t decide how he felt about it. He was sad, and upset that he killed all of them, yet he still claimed to hate them. As a Jedi, shouldn’t he be able to determine the difference between his feelings, and lean on one? Maybe it’s my inability to see what is going on, I don’t know…
3. Star Wars: A New Hope
Oh yes, even the original doesn’t stand up to my test of personal preference…
The Good: This movie is outstanding. For its time, it was visually stunning. Lucas created an entire universe out of nothing, and made is special. This is the movie that started conventions, and fanboys everywhere. It gives us the ultimate battle of good vs. evil. Luke, Darth, Han, 3PO, R2, Obi Wan, and even Greedo. It’s a good movie. I loved the battle of Yavin. The flight down the trenches, Rebels getting picked off one by one by the far superior pilots of the Empire just makes for a great fight scene. Going into it you know the Rebels are going to win, but you can’t beat the feeling you get when you just don’t know. Grand Moff Tarkin is such a perfect villain in this movie. To be realistic, he’s more of the bad guy than Vader in this movie. He has no heart, and has no remorse for destroying the Princess’ home world of Alderan. That thin face gives me nightmares.
What makes this movie so good, is that it can stand on its own. When Lucas was writting and filming, he knew there was a chance it could bomb, and made sure that if this was the only one made, things seemed wrapped up. That’s why the Death Star is destroyed. That’s why Vader’s Tie Fighter gets blown into nothingness. It’s why Luke and Han get medals at the end. Everything could easily be wrapped up right there.
The Bad: The ventilator shaft. The one design flaw in the greatest battle station in history is also the one weakness. It’s just too simple. Sure, it was almost impossible to reach, much less hit. But that’s not the point. The Empire takes two seconds to notice, and the Rebels have nothing to do. The battle is over, Rebel’s lose. Family Guy does it best… http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RcL6DwSufMI
Put that along side Alec Guinness’ weak portrayal, and you have some flaws in the movie. It’s no secret he didn’t want to be there, but he could have at least pulled a Kevin Spacey, and tried to phone it in.
And I hate to bring Family Guy up again, especially in the same tiny section, but Luke’s sudden love of the Force is a bit stupid. He learned about it on Tatooine, and now demands that Han also agree to its creedos. Grow up kid, you’ll never get friends like that.
2. Revenge of the Sith|
This movies puts Episode I and II in toilet. This is the movie everyone was hoping for when they saw Phantom Menace.
The Good: Anakin is finally the whiny brat I expected. His complaints aren’t little anymore. He’s finally upset about something significant: his abilities. Anakin has been told too long he is the Chosen One, and expects so much more. Sure he whines all the time, but why shouldn’t he? The Jedi Council have fed him all this belief of his destiny, and power to destroy the Sith, that he truly believes he is behind in his growth as a Jedi. Palpatine finally becomes the evil Sith Sidious to the public. Sure, we all knew it from Episode I but to see it happen is unreal.
Everything that happens on Mustafar is breathtaking, in my opinion. Starting with the murder of all the Separatists, and ending with the rescue of Vader. However, I must say my favorite parts had to be first, the cloaked face of Vader after the initial attack. It’s right here that you see the last remnant of Anakin still in that body. When Anakin drops that single tear, it become evident that it was the last part of him that was good leaving his body. And of course, we can’t deny the fight scene its proper place. That is what a lightsaber duel should look like. Two equally matched Jedi, going head to head. In earlier duels one was always outmatched, and chance led good to victory over evil. It was chance that Obi Wan defeated Vader, but not the kind of chance that won all the other battles.
Seeing how Anakin physically became Vader still gets me. What all it really took for him to complete that transformation is shocking. Until the moment when Vader is laying next to the river of lava can you really see what he’s like under the suit. He really was more machine than man. And seeing Order 66 be executed really almost made me cry. For reals.
And of course, Yoda. I love Yoda. Going up against the Emperor was no easy task. This fight really shows how powerful Yoda was, but even more so how powerful of a Sith Sidious was. With a few lucky breaks, Yoda defeats the Emperor, and peace can be regained in the galaxy. Like I said, it all comes down to chance.
Oh, and I liked finally seeing more Wookiees. Those things are awesome, and it gave Peter Mayhew a chance to be the only original cast member in the new trilogy. But let’s face it, he needed the work.
The Bad: Anakin does complain too much. Sure, what he complained about was good, but I think Hayden Christainson was just toomuch of a brat. I didn’t like how Obi Wan defeated Grievous with a blaster. Yeah he had a little quip afterwards, but I wanted to see that machine man go down with a lightsaber to the chest. It only made sense.
And what was the deal with the ever changing voice of Palpatine? I realize that he needed to speak differently as a Sith Lord, but after he got owned by Windu he used seventeen different dialects. Pick one, and run with it.
Is it a rule that every Star Wars movie has to have some stupid and pointless alien character? Because when chasing Grievous on Upatau, Obi Wan rode the most bizarre lizard beast of all time. I’m just sick of lame alien creature beasts being in a movie, for the sake of having more creatures. It was like when they added all those Dubacks into A New Hope when it was rereleased. Very pointless.
In the last minutes of the movie, and this is what kinda kills it for me, is the starting of the construction of the first Death Star. Maybe the fault lies with ANH, but between the end of Episode IV and the beginning of Episode VI, a new Death Star is basically complete. So, am I to believe that it took 19 years to build the first one and finally get it completely operational, but somehow after being destroyed in the Battle of Yavin it was almost fully rebuilt and fully operational by the events of Return of the Jedi? Sure, they can’t change Jedi, and I know how cool it was to see Vader and the Emperor watching the Death Star being built, but really? I just don’t buy it.
1. The Empire Strikes Back
In my opinion, the darkest of all the movies, and most definitely the darkest of the original trilogy.
The Good: Oh where to begin… Hoth was my favorite planet. It was a desolate waste land, and the perfect place for the Rebels to hide. The battle on Hoth was unreal, particularly for the time in which it was produced. Luke’s plan to take down the Imperial Walkers was genius. This is the movie that gave us Yoda! And I love Yoda. His entrance in this movie was genius. We all felt like this little goblin might be of importance, but when he finally says that he is Yoda, you have to admit a little shock there. And the fact is, Dagobah basically to me shows how strong Yoda is in the Force. Dagobah was steaming with the Dark Side of the Force, and yet Yoda was able to maintain his Light Side prowess for the entire 23 years he was there in solitude. This is the movie that showed us that despite being dead, deceased Jedi had learned how to commune with the living. Beautiful.
Lando. Lando Calrissian. Yeah, he was a total jerk in this movie. He stabbed his old friend Han in the back, and he essentially turned power of Cloud City over to the Empire. Yeah, that last one was an accident but it still happened under his watch. I still blame him for that.
We have the best line of the entire series in this movie. Leia: “I love you!” Han: “I know.” How ballin is that?!?! No one has the jewels to say that. I’ll argue that by saying this, Han says “I love you” to Leia. But if he had said those three words, everything that made Han Han would have gone down the drain. So hardcore.
Now, that may not be the best line, to some. However, to me it doesn’t get enough credit, and is so underrated. But yes, the most iconic line of the entire film series, from Phantom all the way down to Jedi comes from this little movie. “Luke I am your father.” I think we’ve heard it too many times and it may have lost its edge over time. But think about it for a minute. Think about the way that hit you when you were little. The most evil man in the known galaxy is the father of the hero. The man determined to stop the Empire, to destroy all that is wrong with the galaxy and once agian bring peace and balance to the Force is the offspring of the villain. Wow. I do still get chills when I hear it. Maybe it was the way James Earl Jones said it, but I can’t get the sound of it out of my head.
Luke losing his hand tops off what is great to me. Right after learning that Vader is Luke’s father, Luke loses his hand and has to get a mechanical hand. Luke suddenly became part machine, just like dear old dad.
What I like about this movie, is the ending. The definition of a cliffhanger. Lando takes off with the Falcon, leaving Luke and Leia behind. Han is frozen in carbonite and on his way to Jabba’s palace, and all hope seems lost for the Rebellion. No wrap up. No final happy scene. You have to see the next one. It’s amazing writing. There is no way to argue around it.
The Bad: I hate to bad mouth this movie. This movie sits in the top 3 of my all time movies list. Luke’s attitude this movie bugged me. He left Dagobah before he finished his training, falling straight into Vader’s trap. He freaked out when he learned Vader was his father, and not the good kind of freak out. He didn’t snap, and attack. No, he cried. Like a little baby. I hate that.
Plus there was the awkward kiss between Luke and Leia. I know, we don’t know they are related at this point, but after you see it the second time, after the revelation in Jedi, you can’t not feel creepy.
Well, that’s it. That’s my list of the Star Wars franchise. And yes, I didn’t give a lot of negatives for Empire. But that’s how I roll. Sorry to disappoint. Disagree? Give it to me in the comments.